Tuesday, September 4, 2012

The Five-Passenger Crossover Battle: Chevy Equinox LTZ vs. Nissan Murano SL




Test vehicles MSRP:
Equinox: $32,925
Murano: $39,255

Seating Capacity: 5 occupants

Standard Safety Features:
Equinox LTZ: airbags; ABS; traction control; tire pressure monitoring system; rear vision camera system and rear park assist system

Murano SL: airbags; ABS; traction control; electronic brake distribution; and a tire pressure monitoring system



Standard and Optional Features Included:
Equinox LTZ: 18-inch wheels; leather (heated front) seats; power seats; sliding/reclining rear seat; tilt-and-telescopic steering; cruise control; automatic rearview mirror; OnStar turn-by-turn radio-activated navigation system; power programmable liftgate; a forward collision alert system; and a lane departure warning system

Murano SL: 18-inch wheels; power seats; memory driver’s seat; leather (heated) front seats; leather heated steering wheel; tilt-and-telescopic steering; dual-zone automatic temperature control; keyless push button starter; dual panel sunroof; automatic headlights; power liftgate; and a navigation system with real-time traffic and weather

Standard Audio:
Equinox LTZ: 8-speaker AM/FM//CD Player with 3-month XM satellite radio subscription
Murano SL: 9-speaker Bose AM/FM/CD and dual speaker subwoofer with 3-month XM satellite radio subscription

Bumper-to-Bumper Warranty:
Equinox: 3-year/36,000 miles
Murano: 3-year/ 36,000 miles

Powertrain Warranty:
Equinox: 5-year/100,000 miles
Murano: 5-year/60,000 miles

Bluetooth Compatibility:
Equinox LTZ: Yes
Murano SL: Yes

MP3 Capability:
Equinox LTZ: Yes
Murano SL: Yes

ipod Capability:
Equinox LTZ: No
Murano SL: Yes

Standard Engine/Horsepower:
Equinox LTZ: 3.0-liter, 6-cyl./264-hp
Murano SL: 3.5-liter, 6-cyl./260-hp

Recommended Fuel:
Equinox: Regular
Murano: Premium    
  
Standard Fuel Mileage:
Equinox LTZ: 17-city/24-highway
Murano SL: 18-city/24-highway

Cargo Volume:
Equinox LTZ: 31.5 cu. ft.
Murano SL: 31.6 cu. ft.

What’s New:
Equinox: The current-generation Equinox received its last major overhaul in 2009. Since then, GM has made minor tweaks along the way, keeping the vehicle fresh. For the 2012 model year, the Equinox adds a new seven-inch touchscreen with a USB port. Also all Equinoxs now include blind-spot mirrors. And as far as tech features, the Equinox is now available with a lane-changing departure warning system, a standard back-up camera in upgraded trim levels, Bluetooth connectivity and Chevy’s Mylink system, which integrates smartphones with Pandora and Stitcher. Furthermore, the compact crossover also receives new shoes for the model year, a set of 18-inch chrome wheels are available on upgraded trim levels.

Murano: The curvaceous crossover received a mid-cycle overhaul during the 2011 model year. Besides the mid-year refresh, a high-end Platinum edition is added to line up for the 2012 model year. With this new premium trim package, buyers can expect 20-inch alloy wheels, which will not only improve the overall look, but the ride, too.

The Verdict:  Both crossovers offer a car-like ride, seating for five and loads of high-tech gadgets. With that being the case, there are a number of factors that differentiate both rides. For instance, unlike the more angular exterior design of GM’s Equinox, the curvaceous Murano offers a stylish flair with its swoopy-like design. And, while the Chevy offers a more traditional design, consumers who snap-up the vehicle can expect to save fuel too. Buyers who opt for the Chevy will find that the Equinox requires unleaded fuel, while the Nissan Murano requires premium fuel. Conversely, the premium fuel in the Nissan only garners a slight improvement in fuel economy. For the life of us, we don’t understand why Nissan requires premium fuel in its 6-cylinder in a day and time where consumers are penny pinching.

Moreover, while the Chevy Equinox was outfitted with GM’s signature OnStar system, which includes a 6-month voice-activated, turn-by-turn navigation system, the high-end vehicle trim we reviewed lacked an optional navigation system. Unfortunately, once the 6-months are up, buyers will have to fork out extra money to renew the turn-by-turn voice-activated direction system, live without it, or rely on their smartphone (or some other type of gadget.)

And, unless one is purely driven to buy the Nissan, one can manage to get a well-equipped Chevy for about $6,000 less than the Murano. With that price differential, the Chevy adds a lane departure alert warning system and a forward collision alert system, both a first in this segment for non premium brands. These high-tech safety features are only available in the Chevy when buyers opt for the six-cylinder engine.

Overall, both vehicles offer a lot of bang for the buck. In some cases, pricing for these compact crossovers bump-up against crossovers like Kia’s Sorrento, which offers seven-passenger seating, leather, a six-cylinder engine and dual sunroofs for a hair under $34,000. So as one can tell, this is a buyers market for those seeking an alternative to cars, minivans and traditional truck-like SUVs.

Competition:  Ford Escape, GMC Terrain, Honda CR-V, Hyundai Tucson and Kia Sportage, 

3 comments:

Tyra Shortino said...

I would always go for the car that lets me save costs on fuel since this would add up in the long run. With all the features the dealers would throw in when you buy a Chevy, it’s pretty easy to decide which one to choose. ;)

Tyra Shortino

Kerstin Shed said...

Try to also look into the car parts’ individual prices. Break downs and repairs are often inevitable over time, so it is wise to have an idea about a vehicle’s possible repair costs before you purchase it.

Kerstin Shed

Anonymous said...

Hi, Neat post. There is an issue with your website in web explorer,
could test this? IE still is the market chief and a big section of other people will omit your great writing because
of this problem.

Feel free to surf to my web blog :: airplane game

Auto Analyst Kevin Tynan Talks To 'Auto Trends' About Car Sales, Prices And More

  Kevin Tynan, the Presidio Group's director of research, joins Auto Trends with JeffCars.com to analyze both the new and the used car m...